THIS DAY IN HISTORY:
15 October 1970 International Handwashing Day.1970 Serial killer Andrei Chikatilo was found guilty of 52 murders.1970 Mikhail Gorbachev was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for his contribution to reducing international tension and implementing a policy of transparency.
5 Important Trends of subsidiary liability in bankruptcy
5 Important Trends of subsidiary liability in bankruptcy
The issue of bringing citizens and legal entities to subsidiary liability continues to be relevant among participants in civil cases. The past year 2021 was rich in the positions of the courts on this issue. Vladimir Kuznetsov, the Vice-President of the Association of Lawyers for Registration, Liquidation, Bankruptcy and Legal Representation, told Rusbankrot about the latest trends in the changing practice.
First of all, it is worth noting the points regarding the criteria for bringing to subsidiary liability. Last autumn, two definitions of the Supreme Court of Russia at once contained references to them.
Among the signs that allow satisfying an application for a subsidy liability in relation to a specific person, the following are named:
materiality of the influence of the defendant on the activities of the debtor;
the existence of a tangible negative impact on the debtor and its creditors as a result of the defendant exercising his powers;
proof of participation of the defendant as an initiator, as well as a beneficiary of a substantially unprofitable transaction (it is also possible for the defendant to participate in this jointly with other persons).
Thus, only those whose actions led directly to the insolvency of company, but not any head of debtor by default, can be brought to subsidiary liability (decision
of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation dated 07.10.2021 ¹ 305-ES19-14439 (3-8)).
When considering the issue of bringing to subsidiary liability, the assessment of its size for each of the defendants is an important aspect. In such cases, the highest court considers that the courts should establish the involvement of each specific person in the transactions imputed to him/her by name.
The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation noted that the mere fact of the identity of the positions of several defendants (members of the board, for example) does not mean the same identity of their potential subsidiary liability.
In other words, the highest court encourages colleagues to understand each specific case in detail, establishing the personal influence of the involved entities in determining the scope of their liability to the debtor and creditors (decision
of November 17, 2021 ¹ 305-ES17-7124 (6)).
As for the legal entities that can also be defendants in this category of cases, an interesting remark is provided for them. In the event that the court establishes the fact of labor activity of the debtor's employees in other companies, this circumstance cannot become a basis for bringing the legal entities to subsidiary liability for the debts of the bankrupt.
Thus, the fact of employment relationship of the debtor's employees with other organizations is not unambiguously decisive for establishing affiliation and, as a result, subsidiary liability of these persons (decision
of MAC dated October 21, 2021, ruling
dated January 13, 2022 in case ¹ A40-297262 /2018).
Last spring, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation considered the important issue of bringing to subsidiary liability in case when several companies concluded surety agreements for a group purpose. At the same time, if we consider the scope of obligations, which are accepted by each individual legal entity, then we may say that they may well exceed its financial capabilities. But the established banking practice often requires such a collective guarantee, and companies do this based on the activities of the entire group, which will allow to repay the debt by means of the joint efforts.
In such situations, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation urges colleagues not to rush to bring anyone to subsidiary liability, given that the mere existence of such a guarantee does not indicate bad faith or unreasonable behavior of the head of the company (decision
of 03/25/2021 No. 310-ES20-18954).
Another interesting definition concerns the possibility of bringing the debtor's managers to subsidiary liability after the company is excluded from the Unified State Register of Legal Entities. It would seem that with the entry of such information in the register, both the activities of the legal entity and all claims against it and its leaders should be terminated. However, the Arbitration Court of the North-Western District expressed a different opinion on this matter. In the event that immediately after the liquidation of the company, its participants transfer all the assets to another newly created legal entity, the court should carefully examine the question of the reasons for such actions for the presence of bad faith. In some cases, there may be grounds for bringing the leaders of a company already excluded from the Unified State Register of Legal Entities to subsidiary liability (ruling
of the AC NWD dated October 26, 21 in case ¹ A45-27000 / 2020).
In conclusion, we can say that the jurisprudence has taken a course towards softening approaches to the issues of subsidiary liability for conscientious leaders and managers, introducing criteria for assessing their behavior.
When considering such applications, one should, on the one hand, be guided by a number of signs that allow a positive decision to be made, and, on the other hand, approach each case individually.
As for the statistical data, since 2017 the number of applications for attracting controlling persons to the subsidiary liability has been steadily growing, as well as the total number of positive decisions on such issues. And if in 2017 the number of persons brought to subsidiary liability did not reach one thousand, then in 2020 this figure amounted to more than three thousand. Click here to view
the statistics of cases on bringing to subsidiary liability in 2021.
Website Rusbankrot.ru uses cookies. If you continue to browse our pages, you agree to this condition. You can change the cookie settings in the browser settings.